Important question
- Thread starter Matt76
- Start date
Help Support Nissan Navara Forum:
K
KraftyPg
Guest
It's unfair to expect the loosing team to travel everywhere?
K
KraftyPg
Guest
As expected as the carry on before, during and after the game. I watched five pages on another forum erupt within 3 minutes of the binning incident, it was as fast moving as the game 
CBF looking up the new rule myself so can someone tell me if when a punch is thrown and a player in binned does it also go on report, or does the binning substitute any reporting and possible suspension from that report?
CBF looking up the new rule myself so can someone tell me if when a punch is thrown and a player in binned does it also go on report, or does the binning substitute any reporting and possible suspension from that report?
Thats a very good question actually, i THINK the ref needs to indicate at the time the player is on report. If he does not at the time of the incident there is no such report, but the review committee can outside of the game review the incident and have the player on report.
So i`m lead to believe.
So i`m lead to believe.
K
KraftyPg
Guest
Given the review committee can review anything if that gets taken out of the equation for the time being and someone who throws a punch does get binned in favour of a report, I can't see what the big fuss is.
Throwing a punch is pretty obvious (ok QLD may not think so today but shit happens) so chances are if the ref puts it on report the player will get suspended. If the report isn't instant and the player just gets 10 mins in the bin it seems like a pretty fair deal to me. Also making a team short of players at a possibly tense moment of the match may well make players think twice before trying to prove they are better fighters than players.
Throwing a punch is pretty obvious (ok QLD may not think so today but shit happens) so chances are if the ref puts it on report the player will get suspended. If the report isn't instant and the player just gets 10 mins in the bin it seems like a pretty fair deal to me. Also making a team short of players at a possibly tense moment of the match may well make players think twice before trying to prove they are better fighters than players.
K
KraftyPg
Guest
According to the daily telegraph
So it appears they can and do get reported as well as the binning.
Although if Tate and Bird were cleared it does bring into question as to whether they were wrongfully binned in the first place.
So it appears they can and do get reported as well as the binning.
Although if Tate and Bird were cleared it does bring into question as to whether they were wrongfully binned in the first place.
K
KraftyPg
Guest
There will be a new raft of player/lawyer meetings and instead of Tuesday night tribunal it will be set out for wrongful binning cases and the NRL will get sued for loss of game winnings when teams loose
K
KraftyPg
Guest
I don't care about many sports these days but I still prefer NRL to AFL and really don't see any need for the punch ons but like all sports rules overtake things and get out of hand. Unfortunately sometimes things do need to change to keep moving forward but traditionalists rarely see it and rule makers rarely consider it.
K
KraftyPg
Guest
Yeah but on the football field you go to work, get the shits up and hit someone, thousands scream and you get to stay home from work for a few weeks. In the real world you go to work, hit a co-worker and get sacked and live in poverty until you get a new job. Those party girls on the football field have it sooooo gooood!!!
K
KraftyPg
Guest
The Blues would be a better team and it would be easier to support them if there just wasn't as many NSW players in the team.
04SilverSTR
Member
go qld
Well said.
K
KraftyPg
Guest
NSW supporters seem awfully quiet the last few years, maybe QLD better gift them a series next year just to see if they are still alive.
